Batya Swift Yasgur, MA, LSW
July 22, 2021
Infection with the common parasite Toxoplasma gondii is associated with mild cognitive impairment in otherwise healthy individuals, new research suggests.
Investigators reviewed and conducted a meta-analysis of 13 studies that encompassed more than 13,000 healthy adults and found a modest but significant association between T gondii seropositivity and impaired performance on cognitive tests of processing speed, working memory, short-term verbal memory, and executive function. The average age of the persons in the studies was close to 50 years.
“Our findings show that T gondii could have a negative but small effect on cognition,” study investigator Arjen Sutterland, MD, of the Amsterdam Neuroscience Research Institute and the Amsterdam Institute for Infection and Immunity, University of Amsterdam, the Netherlands, told Medscape Medical News.
The study was published online on July 14 in JAMA Psychiatry.
Mental Illness Link
T gondii is “an intracellular parasite that produces quiescent infection in approximately 30% of humans worldwide,” the authors write. The parasite that causes the infection not only settles in muscle and liver tissue but also can cross the blood-brain barrier and settle quiescently in brain tissue. It can be spread through contact with cat feces or by consuming contaminated meat.
Previous research has shown that neurocognitive changes associated with toxoplasmosis can occur in humans, and meta-analyses suggest an association with neuropsychiatric disorders. Some research has also tied T gondii infection to increased motor vehicle crashes and suicide attempts.
Sutterland said he had been inspired by the work of E. Fuller Torrey and Bob Yolken, who proposed the connection between T gondii and schizophrenia.
Some years ago, Sutterland and his group analyzed the mental health consequences of T gondii infection and found “several interesting associations,” but they were unable to “rule out reverse causation — ie, people with mental health disorders more often get these infections — as well as determine the impact on the population of this common infection.”
For the current study, the investigators analyzed studies that examined specifically cognitive functioning in otherwise healthy individuals in relation to T gondii infection, “because reverse causation would be less likely in this population and a grasp of global impact would become more clear.”
The researchers conducted a literature search of studies conducted through June 7, 2019, that analyzed cognitive function among healthy participants for whom data on T gondii seropositivity were available.
A total of 13 studies (n = 13,289 participants; mean [SD] age, 46.7 [16.0] years; 49.6% male) were used in the review and meta-analysis. Some of the studies enrolled a healthy population sample; other studies compared participants with and those without psychiatric disorders. From these, the researchers extracted only the data concerning healthy participants.
The studies analyzed four cognitive domains: processing speed, working memory, short-term verbal memory, and executive functioning.
All Cognitive Domains Affected
Of all the participants, 22.6% had antibodies against T gondii.
Participants who were seropositive for T gondii had less favorable functioning in all cognitive domains, with “small but significant” differences.
| Domain | Standardized mean difference (95% CI) | P value |
|---|---|---|
| Processing speed (nine studies) | 0.12 (.05 – .19) | .001 |
| Working memory (six studies) | 0.16 (.06 – .26) | .002 |
| Short-term verbal memory (five studies) | 0.18 (.09 – .27) | <.001 |
| Executive functioning (eight studies) | 0.15 (.01 – .28) | .03 |
The researchers conducted a meta-regression analysis of mean age in the analysis of executive functioning and found greater effect sizes as age increased (Q = 6.17; R 2 = 81%; P = .01).
The studies were of “high quality,” and there was “little suggestion of publication bias was detected,” the authors note.
“Although the extent of the associations was modest, the ubiquitous prevalence of the quiescent infection worldwide…suggests that the consequences for cognitive function of the population as a whole may be substantial, although it is difficult to quantify the global impact,” they write.
They note that because the studies were cross-sectional in nature, causality cannot be established.
Nevertheless, Sutterland suggested several possible mechanisms through which T gondii might affect neurocognition.
“We know the parasite forms cysts in the brain and can influence dopaminergic neurotransmission, which, in turn, affects neurocognition. Alternatively, it is also possible that the immune response to the infection in the brain causes cognitive impairment. This remains an important question to explore further,” he said.
He noted that clinicians can reassure patients who test positive for T gondii that although the infection can have a negative impact on cognition, the effect is “small.”
Prevention Programs Warranted
Commenting on the study for Medscape Medical News, Shawn D. Gale, Ph.D., associate professor, Department of Psychology and Neuroscience Center, Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah, called it a “great meta-analysis.” He noted that his group is researching the subject and has obtained similar findings. A big plus is that the researchers assessed several cognitive domains, not just one.
Although the data showed “mild effects,” the findings could be important on a population level. Because 30% of the world’s population are seropositive for T gondii, a potentially large number of people are at risk for cognitive impairment, noted Gale, who was not involved with the study.
“If you look at the United States, perhaps 10% to 15% of people might test positive [for T gondii], but in Germany and France, the number comes closer to 50%, and in other places in the world — especially countries that have a harder time economically — the rates are even higher. So if it can affect cognition, even a small effect is a big deal,” Gale said.
“I think prevention will be the most important thing, and perhaps down the road, I hope that a vaccine will be considered,” Gale added.
“These findings indicate that primary prevention of the infection could have a substantial global impact on mental health” and that public health programs to prevent T gondii infection “are warranted.”
These programs might consist of hygienic measures, especially after human contact with contaminated sources, as well as research into vaccine development.
Leave a Reply